Smokey eyes w/ NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Smoke Liner, Vegan Smokey Eyeliner - Brick Fire (Brick Red). It's a little messy (this is my 1st time using it) so not too bad,
I Bought the NEW NYX SMOKEY LINERS which are easy to use for beginners - YouTube
Buy Nyx Professional Makeup - Automatic Eyeliner Epic Smoke Liner - Black Smoke | Maquibeauty
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Smoke Liner, Vegan Smokey Eyeliner, White Smoke - Walmart.com